CAR/PIT: Guess Who's a PENGUIN Again ;)?

[Robin Hood]

To Carolina

Vernon Fiddler
Andy Greene

To Pittburgh

Ryan O'Reilly
Ryan Shannon
Darcy Tucker
Steve Staois
2011 4th Rounder (VAN)
2012 3rd Rounder (CAR)
2012 4th Rounder (CAR)

[Radiohead]

Confirmed.

Hopefully Greene has another decent season.

[bills09]

pittsburgh kills this imo

[Radiohead]

Meh, even if he did, there's almost no risk.

Other than O'Reilly, I gave up scrubs with practically no fantasy value.

[Robin Hood]

just for those who are gaga over O'Reilly. Fiddlers stat line is SOLID. in comparison to O'Reilly as well. imo fiddler is one of the BEST depth centers to have. and nate got andy greene. solid deal for both teams imo.

[armandtanzarian]

oh dear...

[Radiohead]

Sex. Steve Martin. Teri Hatcher.

[Radiohead]

Nice double edit job, btw. Just so everyone else can get in on the bashing:

Pre-edit 1: Mike Milbury comparison

Pre-edit 2: Carolina will have difficulty getting the GP min and salary cap min

[Scott]

wow, horrible

[Robin Hood]

Everyone is overreacting. Check this:

http://bbkl.hockey.cbssports.com/player ... :p/scoring

[bills09]

Oreilly is 18.

[armandtanzarian]

Nice double edit job, btw. Just so everyone else can get in on the bashing:

Pre-edit 1: Mike Milbury comparison

Pre-edit 2: Carolina will have difficulty getting the GP min and salary cap min

I deleted it because its your team and your decisions. No need to stir shit...

[Radiohead]

I deleted it because its your team and your decisions. No need to stir shit...

You stirred the shit. I kept it going.

[armandtanzarian]

You stirred the shit. I kept it going.

It was there for less than one minute. You plunged the turds out of the sewer that were already a passing thought

[Nick]

come on guys. seriously how does this deal even get on the table, let alone earn a reply or get accepted.

just brutal.

[Radiohead]

Just brutal. Wow horrible. Oh dear. Pittsburgh kills.

Four responses with no insight.

[Scott]

Does the trade really need insight as to why it's bad?

[bills09]

please insight me on how this trade is good for you sir.

[Radiohead]

I'm trading one asset with value. The rest are garbage and don't give me the games played BS.

Greene is likely gonna take over as the #2 dman in New Jersey. He's still relatively young, with a solid cap hit. Fiddler is underrated and offers the same stats as O'Reilly, albeit doesn't have the offensive potential O'Reilly offers.

Btw, Shiv traded:

Pavel Kubina
1st
3rd
4th
4th
5th
Future considerations

for

Andy Greene

[Scott]

Those "garbage" assets can still gain you assets Nate.. hence why I'm sure Shiv wanted them in the deal.. he sees the potential to gain from these "garbage" pieces. Staios, Tucker, & Shannon are NHL players and I can think of a few GMs around the league that could use a few of those..

You gave up the best (by a landslide) asset when it comes to BBKL value and the bigger package.. I completely do not understand this trade.