Fantasy Baseball Keeper League

Anything goes here OT stuff is OK too!
User avatar
Shoalzie
PostsCOLON 12673
JoinedCOLON Mon May 03, 2010 7:28 pm
LocationCOLON Portland, MI
CONTACTCOLON

Re: Fantasy Baseball Keeper League

Post by Shoalzie »

MSP4LYFE wroteCOLON
Fair Deals Steve wroteCOLONShoalzie, would you want to be on the CC?

Im not sure about a Salary cap yet, might be hard in year 1, but it's something we could certainly discuss.
Why have a salary cap? There is no cap limit in baseball, and with the new TV revenue coming in FA salaries are going through the roof.

Yeah, I think salaries are going to be too hard to keep track.

I think we'll have to have rules on number of prospects and maybe how long you can keep guys. You pretty much need to just treat players as their own assets without salaries because how are you going to determine what is cap number or would we actually use real team budgets? We'd have to come up with our own way to determine each team's payroll...that is going to be a nightmare and some teams aren't going to like being limited to spending compared to others.

I think just having everyone start off with a club as constructed...it's on them to build a winner through trades and drafts. Maybe we have some kind of a term limit or contract length and possibly have an element of free agency through auction budgets. Perhaps we can use actual contract lengths instead of salaries to determine how long you can keep guys.
DETROIT RED WINGS | ROSTER | FANTRAX
User avatar
MSP4LYFE
PostsCOLON 11503
JoinedCOLON Mon May 03, 2010 4:22 pm
LocationCOLON Mississauga, Ontario
CONTACTCOLON

Re: Fantasy Baseball Keeper League

Post by MSP4LYFE »

Not to mention that there is no capgeek for baseball, cotts is the closest thing and it doesn't keep track of every individual player, and can be slow to update.
Image
User avatar
MSP4LYFE
PostsCOLON 11503
JoinedCOLON Mon May 03, 2010 4:22 pm
LocationCOLON Mississauga, Ontario
CONTACTCOLON

Re: Fantasy Baseball Keeper League

Post by MSP4LYFE »

The more pressing issue is this, can we find a host to seperate the two leagues (AL and NL), mimic MLB's playoff format, and somehow account for the fact that the NL doesn't use a DH.
Image
User avatar
Shoalzie
PostsCOLON 12673
JoinedCOLON Mon May 03, 2010 7:28 pm
LocationCOLON Portland, MI
CONTACTCOLON

Re: Fantasy Baseball Keeper League

Post by Shoalzie »

Yeah, my assumption would be to not use salaries...not easy information to track down as you said.

If we can find contract length, we can do something with term limits...basically have free agency when a contract expires and then have an auction in the offseason. Auction amounts could carry over each year and you can win money through different rewards...winning and players winning individual awards. It's probably the only way to allow teams taking on the likes of the Astros or the Marlins to be able to improve unless they rob a team blind in some trades or they draft great prospects.

If you have a free agency auction, we can also copy the MLB system where you can lose draft picks as compensation. Any player that is non-tendered doesn't include compensation if you "sign" them. Also, you can't actually trade draft picks in baseball...only players.

I'm totally nerding out right now thinking about what all we could do...Rule 5 draft, waiver trade deadline, roster expansion late in the season, player options for the minors, the playoff system. This is going to be great!
DETROIT RED WINGS | ROSTER | FANTRAX
User avatar
Shoalzie
PostsCOLON 12673
JoinedCOLON Mon May 03, 2010 7:28 pm
LocationCOLON Portland, MI
CONTACTCOLON

Re: Fantasy Baseball Keeper League

Post by Shoalzie »

MSP4LYFE wroteCOLONThe more pressing issue is this, can we find a host to seperate the two leagues (AL and NL), mimic MLB's playoff format, and somehow account for the fact that the NL doesn't use a DH.

Yeah, the lineup issues will be interesting...do we have the interleague rules with the DH where the DH is only used in the AL park? Do we actually use pitchers' hitting stats? Or do we just use a full 25-man roster each week in the head-to-head?

I'd like to think you'd want to include the entire 25-man roster each week...you must have a full positional lineup (catcher, 4 infielders, 3 outfielders), a bench, a 5-man rotation and a bullpen.
DETROIT RED WINGS | ROSTER | FANTRAX
User avatar
Tony
PostsCOLON 11222
JoinedCOLON Mon May 03, 2010 10:29 pm
LocationCOLON Nevada

Re: Fantasy Baseball Keeper League

Post by Tony »

as the GM of Oakland, no salaries is a good thing
Image
Click banner to view current roster and picks
User avatar
MSP4LYFE
PostsCOLON 11503
JoinedCOLON Mon May 03, 2010 4:22 pm
LocationCOLON Mississauga, Ontario
CONTACTCOLON

Re: Fantasy Baseball Keeper League

Post by MSP4LYFE »

Shoalzie wroteCOLONYeah, my assumption would be to not use salaries...not easy information to track down as you said.

If we can find contract length, we can do something with term limits...basically have free agency when a contract expires and then have an auction in the offseason. Auction amounts could carry over each year and you can win money through different rewards...winning and players winning individual awards. It's probably the only way to allow teams taking on the likes of the Astros or the Marlins to be able to improve unless they rob a team blind in some trades or they draft great prospects.

If you have a free agency auction, we can also copy the MLB system where you can lose draft picks as compensation. Any player that is non-tendered doesn't include compensation if you "sign" them. Also, you can't actually trade draft picks in baseball...only players.

I'm totally nerding out right now thinking about what all we could do...Rule 5 draft, waiver trade deadline, roster expansion late in the season, player options for the minors, the playoff system. This is going to be great!
I despise that idea, it devalues players with expiring contracts, and is impossible to replicate FA in any meaningful way. If lower end teams want to improve, they need to draft well, and make smart trades, same as any other team.
Image
User avatar
MSP4LYFE
PostsCOLON 11503
JoinedCOLON Mon May 03, 2010 4:22 pm
LocationCOLON Mississauga, Ontario
CONTACTCOLON

Re: Fantasy Baseball Keeper League

Post by MSP4LYFE »

Shoalzie wroteCOLONYeah, my assumption would be to not use salaries...not easy information to track down as you said.

If we can find contract length, we can do something with term limits...basically have free agency when a contract expires and then have an auction in the offseason. Auction amounts could carry over each year and you can win money through different rewards...winning and players winning individual awards. It's probably the only way to allow teams taking on the likes of the Astros or the Marlins to be able to improve unless they rob a team blind in some trades or they draft great prospects.

If you have a free agency auction, we can also copy the MLB system where you can lose draft picks as compensation. Any player that is non-tendered doesn't include compensation if you "sign" them. Also, you can't actually trade draft picks in baseball...only players.

I'm totally nerding out right now thinking about what all we could do...Rule 5 draft, waiver trade deadline, roster expansion late in the season, player options for the minors, the playoff system. This is going to be great!
You can under the new CBA, in fact it has already happened twice.
Image
User avatar
MSP4LYFE
PostsCOLON 11503
JoinedCOLON Mon May 03, 2010 4:22 pm
LocationCOLON Mississauga, Ontario
CONTACTCOLON

Re: Fantasy Baseball Keeper League

Post by MSP4LYFE »

Shoalzie wroteCOLON
MSP4LYFE wroteCOLONThe more pressing issue is this, can we find a host to seperate the two leagues (AL and NL), mimic MLB's playoff format, and somehow account for the fact that the NL doesn't use a DH.

Yeah, the lineup issues will be interesting...do we have the interleague rules with the DH where the DH is only used in the AL park? Do we actually use pitchers' hitting stats? Or do we just use a full 25-man roster each week in the head-to-head?

I'd like to think you'd want to include the entire 25-man roster each week...you must have a full positional lineup (catcher, 4 infielders, 3 outfielders), a bench, a 5-man rotation and a bullpen.
Is there anyway to do a regular season rotisserie league, followed by H2H in the playoffs? That would be ideal, additionally H2H baseball during the regular season is a bad idea, nothing is more meaningless and unpredictable than a baseball match-up over a one week sample size.
Image
User avatar
Shoalzie
PostsCOLON 12673
JoinedCOLON Mon May 03, 2010 7:28 pm
LocationCOLON Portland, MI
CONTACTCOLON

Re: Fantasy Baseball Keeper League

Post by Shoalzie »

MSP4LYFE wroteCOLONI despise that idea, it devalues players with expiring contracts, and is impossible to replicate FA in any meaningful way. If lower end teams want to improve, they need to draft well, and make smart trades, same as any other team.
If you want to match the BBKL, then you leave out free agency and just use trades, drafts and waivers. My only thing is how do we distribute the remaining unsigned veteran free agents?

MSP4LYFE wroteCOLONYou can under the new CBA, in fact it has already happened twice.
I must've missed that...what trades involved picks?

All I know is I'm not interested in a 30-round draft each year. :lol:

Is there anyway to do a regular season rotisserie league, followed by H2H in the playoffs? That would be ideal, additionally H2H baseball during the regular season is a bad idea, nothing is more meaningless and unpredictable than a baseball match-up over a one week sample size.
That's an interesting idea...wouldn't have to worry about regular season schedules that way. But baseball has a long regular season so you'd think the right teams will be the best teams if we did H2H all season.

You'd still want to keep the leagues and divisions as is and then use the MLB 10-team playoffs with H2H as you said.
Last edited by 1 on Shoalzie, edited 0 times in total.
DETROIT RED WINGS | ROSTER | FANTRAX
User avatar
The BBKL Insider
PostsCOLON 22628
JoinedCOLON Mon May 03, 2010 8:46 pm
LocationCOLON San Juan, Puerto Rico

Re: Fantasy Baseball Keeper League

Post by The BBKL Insider »

Shoalzie wroteCOLON
MSP4LYFE wroteCOLONThe more pressing issue is this, can we find a host to seperate the two leagues (AL and NL), mimic MLB's playoff format, and somehow account for the fact that the NL doesn't use a DH.

Yeah, the lineup issues will be interesting...do we have the interleague rules with the DH where the DH is only used in the AL park? Do we actually use pitchers' hitting stats? Or do we just use a full 25-man roster each week in the head-to-head?

I'd like to think you'd want to include the entire 25-man roster each week...you must have a full positional lineup (catcher, 4 infielders, 3 outfielders), a bench, a 5-man rotation and a bullpen.
Having Shoalzie is going to be great, his knowledge seems to be what ours is about hockey!

For the starting rotations this is what i was thinking : "you must have a full positional lineup (catcher, 4 infielders, 3 outfielders), a bench, a 5-man rotation and a bullpen." Maybe add 1 DH for AL and include all stats for pitchers in the NL? so their batting stats count?
Image
User avatar
The BBKL Insider
PostsCOLON 22628
JoinedCOLON Mon May 03, 2010 8:46 pm
LocationCOLON San Juan, Puerto Rico

Re: Fantasy Baseball Keeper League

Post by The BBKL Insider »

Shoalzie wroteCOLON
MSP4LYFE wroteCOLONI despise that idea, it devalues players with expiring contracts, and is impossible to replicate FA in any meaningful way. If lower end teams want to improve, they need to draft well, and make smart trades, same as any other team.
If you want to match the BBKL, then you leave out free agency and just use trades, drafts and waivers. My only thing is how do we distribute the remaining unsigned veteran free agents?

MSP4LYFE wroteCOLONYou can under the new CBA, in fact it has already happened twice.
I must've missed that...what trades involved picks?

All I know is I'm not interested in a 30-round draft each year. :lol:

Is there anyway to do a regular season rotisserie league, followed by H2H in the playoffs? That would be ideal, additionally H2H baseball during the regular season is a bad idea, nothing is more meaningless and unpredictable than a baseball match-up over a one week sample size.
That's an interesting idea...wouldn't have to worry about regular season schedules that way. But baseball has a long regular season so you'd think the right teams will be the best teams if we did H2H all season.

You'd still want to keep the leagues and divisions as is and then use the MLB 10-team playoffs with H2H as you said.
I was thinking no Free Agency in our league, like Kareem said, it complete kills the value of expiring contracted players.

As for FA's in the real MLB - we'd just assign them to the teams that eventually sign them, so lets say A-Rod is a FA (which is isn't), but lets say he is, and the Red Sox sign him, then josh would benefit from that.

This would be a 1 time thing only, after all players had teams we wouldn't do this every summer, the rest could go into a player draft (like we do in the bbkl)

Also - like Shoalzie said we can't run 30 plus rounds in the draft, i was thinking 5-10 rounds each year?
Image
User avatar
Shoalzie
PostsCOLON 12673
JoinedCOLON Mon May 03, 2010 7:28 pm
LocationCOLON Portland, MI
CONTACTCOLON

Re: Fantasy Baseball Keeper League

Post by Shoalzie »

So, do we really need to worry about the 40-man roster until the baseball season starts? They'll sign guys up until the season. Maybe have a cut-off when spring training starts?
DETROIT RED WINGS | ROSTER | FANTRAX
User avatar
MSP4LYFE
PostsCOLON 11503
JoinedCOLON Mon May 03, 2010 4:22 pm
LocationCOLON Mississauga, Ontario
CONTACTCOLON

Re: Fantasy Baseball Keeper League

Post by MSP4LYFE »

Fair Deals Steve wroteCOLONFor the starting rotations this is what i was thinking : "you must have a full positional lineup (catcher, 4 infielders, 3 outfielders), a bench, a 5-man rotation and a bullpen." Maybe add 1 DH for AL and include all stats for pitchers in the NL? so their batting stats count?
That is a given, the problem arises when AL teams face NL teams, obviously an AL team with a DH has an edge over an NL team that utilizes a SP or PH in the same spot.
Image
User avatar
MSP4LYFE
PostsCOLON 11503
JoinedCOLON Mon May 03, 2010 4:22 pm
LocationCOLON Mississauga, Ontario
CONTACTCOLON

Re: Fantasy Baseball Keeper League

Post by MSP4LYFE »

Shoalzie wroteCOLONI must've missed that...what trades involved picks?

All I know is I'm not interested in a 30-round draft each year. :lol:
I can't remember the specific players involved, I just remember that it's happened twice, here is some evidence of what I am talking about however:
Now that Major League Baseball has gone through its first Draft and signing period under the new rules of the Collective Bargaining Agreement, it's time to move on to the next phase of the new system: the Competitive Balance Lottery.

The lottery, scheduled to take place Wednesday at 1:30 p.m. ET in New York, is a mechanism designed to help teams perceived to need the most assistance by awarding extra Draft picks to some of them. The 10 smallest-market teams and 10 lowest-revenue teams will have the chance to win one of six extra selections in the 2013 First-Year Player Draft.

Those half-dozen picks will be made at the conclusion of the first round, following the compensation selections. Because there is obvious crossover between those two groups, there are 13 teams entered into the first-round lottery: the D-backs, Orioles, Indians, Royals, A's, Pirates, Padres, Rays, Reds, Rockies, Marlins, Brewers and Cardinals. The odds of winning a Draft pick will be based on each team's winning percentage in the previous season.

There will be a second group of six picks, to be made after the conclusion of the second round. The teams from the first group that did not get one of the early picks will be re-entered, along with any other Major League team that receives revenue sharing. This year, only one team -- the Tigers -- will be added to the second lottery. The Competitive Balance Lottery winners and the order of their picks will be unveiled on MLB Network's "The Rundown" at 2:45 p.m. ET.

"[We just finished] off the first Draft with the new CBA," Pirates assistant general manager Greg Smith said. "No club, no scouting director, no scout had gone through that landscape [before]. The Competitive Balance picks will be the same thing. Clubs value Draft picks and the ability to have them, to add to them, even to trade them. As you try to acquire talent through the Draft or if you're trying to improve the big league club, then the picks become a part of that process."

Smith brought up one of the more intriguing aspects of this new process -- the picks that come out of it are commodities. For the first time in Major League history, Draft picks can be dealt. But there are a series of conditions and limitations regarding such transactions.

Only a team that wins a pick in the lottery can trade it, meaning that selection can be traded just once. It can't be sold for cash, and it may only be dealt during the season. Trading can commence the day after the lottery is held and is allowed until the end of that regular season. So seeing a lottery pick or two involved in some July 31 Trade Deadline deals is a possibility. They cannot be included in any Winter Meetings deals, however, with trading of picks again permitted at the beginning of the following regular season.

So the Pirates, or any team that might be involved in Deadline deals this month, can use a pick they receive in this lottery in their trade negotiations. How the picks are valued might vary from team to team, and trying to get a sense of their worth in an open market definitely falls under the "to be determined" category, but it does add something to the trading landscape.

"With us battling trying to stay on top, now in our efforts to improve the club, how do you factor [the picks] in? I think you do," Smith said. "It's going to be interesting because it's something that hasn't been there. There's potential for it to be a part of the overall dialogue as we get closer [to the Deadline]. It's a new twist.

"Some clubs value those differently. Some clubs might put a higher value on those types of picks than other teams, who might rather have a known player. But it adds to the intrigue."
http://mlb.mlb.com/news/article.jsp?ymd ... d=35035642
Shoalzie wroteCOLONThat's an interesting idea...wouldn't have to worry about regular season schedules that way. But baseball has a long regular season so you'd think the right teams will be the best teams if we did H2H all season.

You'd still want to keep the leagues and divisions as is and then use the MLB 10-team playoffs with H2H as you said.
The possibility of H2H match-ups arbitrarily working themselves out does not validate their use in the first place, I much prefer a roto league in the regular season because it ensures that the beast teams make it into the post season. This is especially important in baseball because of the limited amount of teams who qualify for the playoffs.
Image
bills09
PostsCOLON 9280
JoinedCOLON Mon May 03, 2010 5:10 pm
LocationCOLON Pickering, Ontario

Re: Fantasy Baseball Keeper League

Post by bills09 »

why not just run all teams with a DH is that not possible?
Image
User avatar
MSP4LYFE
PostsCOLON 11503
JoinedCOLON Mon May 03, 2010 4:22 pm
LocationCOLON Mississauga, Ontario
CONTACTCOLON

Re: Fantasy Baseball Keeper League

Post by MSP4LYFE »

bills09 wroteCOLONwhy not just run all teams with a DH is that not possible?
Because only half of MLB employs a DH, therefore there are not enough DH's for all 30 teams.
Image
User avatar
kimmer
PostsCOLON 18090
JoinedCOLON Thu Sep 02, 2010 2:25 pm
LocationCOLON Ontario, Canada

Re: Fantasy Baseball Keeper League

Post by kimmer »

Yea, if the half DH rule can't be implemented, then the only other way is to just take out DH altogether for both leagues and add a util slot for guys like big papi
User avatar
Shoalzie
PostsCOLON 12673
JoinedCOLON Mon May 03, 2010 7:28 pm
LocationCOLON Portland, MI
CONTACTCOLON

Re: Fantasy Baseball Keeper League

Post by Shoalzie »

MSP4LYFE wroteCOLON
bills09 wroteCOLONwhy not just run all teams with a DH is that not possible?
Because only half of MLB employs a DH, therefore there are not enough DH's for all 30 teams.

To be fair, there will be interleague play all season now that there is an even 15-15 split in the AL and NL...we'll see the NL playing with a DH throughout the season when they're in AL parks. I think we either have to use it for everyone or we don't. However, if we don't use the DH...you're hurting half the league who has a quality DH (Ortiz, Martinez, et al) and if you use pitcher batting stats, you're hurting the other half of the league. We have to have one way or the other.

My vote is that every uses a 9th hitter (DH or UTIL) and we just let pitchers be pitchers. Pitchers only hurt hitting stats unless we're doing roto where it'll all even out in the end. I think most teams are capable of playing one extra hitter every week. This is probably the best argument for roto since weekly, a team might be at a disadvantage because most of their team may not be involved in games with a DH...namely, all the NL teams.
DETROIT RED WINGS | ROSTER | FANTRAX
User avatar
MSP4LYFE
PostsCOLON 11503
JoinedCOLON Mon May 03, 2010 4:22 pm
LocationCOLON Mississauga, Ontario
CONTACTCOLON

Re: Fantasy Baseball Keeper League

Post by MSP4LYFE »

Shoalzie wroteCOLONTo be fair, there will be interleague play all season now that there is an even 15-15 split in the AL and NL...we'll see the NL playing with a DH throughout the season when they're in AL parks. I think we either have to use it for everyone or we don't. However, if we don't use the DH...you're hurting half the league who has a quality DH (Ortiz, Martinez, et al) and if you use pitcher batting stats, you're hurting the other half of the league. We have to have one way or the other.

My vote is that every uses a 9th hitter (DH or UTIL) and we just let pitchers be pitchers. Pitchers only hurt hitting stats unless we're doing roto where it'll all even out in the end. I think most teams are capable of playing one extra hitter every week. This is probably the best argument for roto since weekly, a team might be at a disadvantage because most of their team may not be involved in games with a DH...namely, all the NL teams.
I agree on all points, Scott.
Image
BUTTON_POST_REPLY

Return to