Yahoo Keeper Dilemma - Duchesne vs Schwartz

[Chuck Norris]

Who would you take? Standard scoring cats. Duchesne is having a terrible year (only 2 PPPts all year not to mention bad pts totals). Schwartz has finally broken out but is his A game as good as Duchesne's? (Don't think so but wanted your guys take). Any and all opinions are very much appreciated.

[kimmer]

if no FOW then Schwartz easily

[Chuck Norris]

No FOW.

[bills09]

Keeper Duchene
1 year Schwartz

[hong57]

i'd say Duchene... he can have a slow year to start with...
btw why are you asking? why do you have to drop someone? and if you are dropping someone your team is that deep that you can't keep both?

[hong57]

and I don't think Schwartz would be available in free agent mkt unless your leagues has only 2 teams...?

[The BBKL Insider]

Duchene

[Chuck Norris]

I'm about to start a firesale on my yahoo team. Needed to determine who my keepers are going to be for next year so I can sell off the rest.

[Arian The Insider]

well duchesne has been retired for a while now so I'd look to move him and keep schwartz

[Handsome&FairMike]

Schwartz will get more return this year so trade him and keep duchene. Similar long term IMO

[Nick]

I was going to say the exact opposite of HFM. Duchene worth more, similar long term, get the best deal.