Official: Everything S.Crosby VS C.McDavid

[kyuss]

So my question is does McDavid have the personal qualities/traits to lead an entire city out of the dungeon and back to NHL respectability as like Crosby? I don't know. It is an intriguing question. .

It will be hardly comparable as I don't think McDavid will be supported by a player as good as himself..

So you think this ARZ melt down is a one-year blip and there is little chance of them repeating a top three pick

being a bottom 3 team doesn't mean having the chance to select a Malkin... something Pittsburgh already had done when they were gifted Crosby

[Nick]

ARI is not without some serious talent in their prospect pipeline. I believe their blueline & crease are in great shape, and with forwards coming along like henrik Sammy, duclair, domi - and vertans to shelter their arrival like Doan & Hanzal - I wouldn't be surprised to see a very quick and exciting turn around.

[kimmer]

So my question is does McDavid have the personal qualities/traits to lead an entire city out of the dungeon and back to NHL respectability as like Crosby? I don't know. It is an intriguing question. .

It will be hardly comparable as I don't think McDavid will be supported by a player as good as himself..

So you think this ARZ melt down is a one-year blip and there is little chance of them repeating a top three pick?

To keep it on topic though: it is worth noting the types of players these guys play with does impact overall value of the player. Crosby had Malkin, J.Staal, Fluery, Letang etc. Gretzky in EDM had Messier, Coffey, Kurri, etc, and in LAK he had lucky luc, Nicholls, Duchene. If McDavid can play with other elite talent, it will make him more valued.

Lol bro. Like I said ALL and all aspects of these players are allowed to be discussed. There's no limit to this topic. I dont care if a dude felt like saying 'crosby the best!' and leave it at that for all I care

All I meant was that let's not KEEP this topic one dimensionally. Mebe it just came out wrong. If u think franchise/external factors an interesting discussion, go ahead and post it!

[LeanMachine]

So my question is does McDavid have the personal qualities/traits to lead an entire city out of the dungeon and back to NHL respectability as like Crosby? I don't know. It is an intriguing question. .

It will be hardly comparable as I don't think McDavid will be supported by a player as good as himself..

So you think this ARZ melt down is a one-year blip and there is little chance of them repeating a top three pick

being a bottom 3 team doesn't mean having the chance to select a Malkin... something Pittsburgh already had done when they were gifted Crosby

lol what. you didn't answer my question (not surprised).

being a bottom three team DOES mean a player Malkin-"like" could be available. That Sean Day looks pretty unreal and there's that kid from Europe can't think of his name right now.

And who cares when the supporting cast comes for McDavid? Before or after...doesn't matter.

[LeanMachine]

This is the kid I was saying:



kid is friggin 16 yrs old and he is already 6'3 200 playing in top finish league at 0.5 pts/game like wtf

[The BBKL Insider]

This is the kid I was saying:



kid is friggin 16 yrs old and he is already 6'3 200 playing in top finish league at 0.5 pts/game like wtf

i'd say he's probably done growing. I've had my full size since i was 14 ish.

[LeanMachine]

Or then there is the Matthews kid. Check out where he was born. imagine ARZ get him w/ McDavid:

[Arian The Insider]

Interesting fact about Matthews: He's half Mexican

[LeanMachine]

Interesting fact about Matthews: He's half Mexican

Are you serious?? wow how does this kid NOT get drafted by ARZ? match made in heaven

[Arian The Insider]

Interesting fact about Matthews: He's half Mexican

Are you serious?? wow how does this kid NOT get drafted by ARZ? match made in heaven

lol ya seriously. would be great for that franchise and hockey in that state.

[kyuss]

So my question is does McDavid have the personal qualities/traits to lead an entire city out of the dungeon and back to NHL respectability as like Crosby? I don't know. It is an intriguing question. .

It will be hardly comparable as I don't think McDavid will be supported by a player as good as himself..

So you think this ARZ melt down is a one-year blip and there is little chance of them repeating a top three pick

being a bottom 3 team doesn't mean having the chance to select a Malkin... something Pittsburgh already had done when they were gifted Crosby

lol what. you didn't answer my question (not surprised).

I didn't think it was necessary to answer a question that has an obvious answer.. they obviously have a chance at picking top 3 again.

Guys like Malkin are very rarely available however. And LOL at Sean Day being in the conversation.

[LeanMachine]

Interesting fact about Matthews: He's half Mexican

Are you serious?? wow how does this kid NOT get drafted by ARZ? match made in heaven

lol ya seriously. would be great for that franchise and hockey in that state.

Interesting point. Not sure if he is McDavid type talent? what do you think.

[Arian The Insider]

Well I personally haven't seen him outside of the WJC so not enough to have a valid opinion. He's the number one prospect for 2016 I believe but from what I've read he doesn't seem to have McDavid potential. I'm interested in seeing how he's rated compared to Eichel, who would be a #1 in most drafts IMO.

[LeanMachine]

Well I personally haven't seen him outside of the WJC so not enough to have a valid opinion. He's the number one prospect for 2016 I believe but from what I've read he doesn't seem to have McDavid potential. I'm interested in seeing how he's rated compared to Eichel, who would be a #1 in most drafts IMO.

Well what I heard of Eichel is that he is only a small step behind McDavid. If Matthews gets compared to Eichel, then that is pretty impressive.

[Matthew]

I like the idea of mcdavid in Arizona and Eichel in buffalo and hanifin in Edmonton.

Mcdavid saves Arizona.

Eichel goes to new York state, which seems like a good place for what will likely be one of the best American centre men ever.

Hanifin gives Edmonton an elite dman. Package him with the black dman next year. And finally get that franchise moving in the right direction...maybe.

I just absolutely do not want to see mcdavid or Eichel in Edmonton. That city has squandered the young years of enough top young forwards.

[Matthew]

Gm benning said he thinks the 2016 draft is better than the 2015 draft. (except the top 2 pieces)

[Arian The Insider]

If the Leafs can't get McDavid I hope Arizona does. If the Leafs were to finish in the same position as me in BBKL and won the lottery that would be perfect lol.

[kimmer]

If there's rigging of drafts why wudnt we logically assume the big bad rich leafs can't buy their way to McDavid lol

[The BBKL Insider]

If it's rigged the leafs will get him. It's time the league took pity on them

[Lee]

Yeah, this draft really doesn't seem that special outside of McDavid and Eichel, then the drop off until 7 ish being average for that group ... maybe a little above average , then nothing spectacular.