Scherbak + 1st

[Lee]

Like for real.

Scherbak didn't accomplish any mind blowing progression this season. He had 4 more points than his draft year. He was invisible at the world juniors. He also has a poor defensive game. Oleksiak's main attribute is that he is really tall. He has 10 points in 59 games in the NHL. It must be his staggering 17 points in the AHL. The first will probably be late again.

[Arian The Insider]

Dude you just asked for the equivalent of 3 1sts for Sam Gagner. Maybe it was a typo or I understood it wrong?

[Lee]

I'll give you Filatov and Biggs for someone real good, Arian. First round picks, one was 6th overall and the others is Leafs property.

[Lee]

I'll even throw in Wolski, 21st overall.

[Arian The Insider]

Pretty dumb to compare Oleksiak and Scherbak to Filatov and Biggs right now lol

[Arian The Insider]

And Gagner is considered real good? Lol

[Lee]

I'm not comparing them, I'm using them to point out how stupid your argument is.

The fact that Oleksiak was a first has no bearing on where he is right now. That hasn't matter since his draft day.

Same with Scherbak, he has show little progression in his game since being drafted last year and has some major holes in his game.

[Arian The Insider]

I'm not comparing them, I'm using them to point out how stupid your argument is.

The fact that Oleksiak was a first has no bearing on where he is right now. That hasn't matter since his draft day.

Same with Scherbak, he has show little progression in his game since being drafted last year and has some major holes in his game.

I meant the equivalent of 3 firsts because the 2 prospects are likely worth a 1st each. Sorry I didn't make that clear.

Just like how Gagner has shown little progression in the last 8 years of his NHL career since being drafted and has major holes in his game?

[Lee]

He's been a 40 point NHLer on dumpster fire team since he was drafted. Hit 49 and 47 before along with 38 in 48 during the lock out.

[The BBKL Insider]

Why does lee have to turn everything into an argument. Obviously that is an awful offer. Even he has to think that.

[Lee]

So what is he worth?

[The BBKL Insider]

I dont know. Depends on the person I suppose. Bit certainly not worth okeksky alone imo.

maybe a late 1st + lesser player or B prospect

[Lee]

Yeah there's not a chance I'd trade a 40 point 25 year old player for one thing that might have a chance to do that some day and another thing that has a large chance of never making an impact.

[kyuss]

Like for real.

Scherbak didn't accomplish any mind blowing progression this season. He had 4 more points than his draft year. He was invisible at the world juniors

well, for that matter, it's pretty hard to be visible at an event you're not attending

[Lee]

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IIHF_World ... ampionship

He played 2 games.

http://www.eliteprospects.com/player.php?player=209468

[Matthew]

1. Those 2 games weren't WJC, they were the 2 games for the Subway Super Series.

2. Get the fuck out of my thread, derailer.