CAR/PHI

[kimmer]

To Carolina

2011 5th rd (CHI)

To Philadelphia

Bertilsson, Simon D PHI

[Lee]

Confirmed

[Nick]

wait... new guy... bcool or an admin approved this one? You need to use a different buddy; perhaps ask around more cause these are not going well.

[bma]

wait... new guy... bcool or an admin approved this one? You need to use a different buddy; perhaps ask around more cause these are not going well.

I didn't approve it. I come home and the trade is posted.

[Scott]

Just fyi. I approved this deal. Paul came to me with what was offered and explained why he wanted to make it (had 61 skaters, lack of picks) and Bertilsson's injury history. I said ok, you've stated your case well, go for it. I just figure just because I don't like the deal there is no reason for me to stop it.

If the offer was for his key players etc I'd advise differently... but Paul stated his case to me just fine.

[Scott]

And ftr, Bertilsson's shit

[Shep]

And ftr, Bertilsson's shit

I concur.

[MSP4LYFE]

thirded.

[Nick]

19 year old dman playing in the SEL, 3rd round pick from a much stronger draft (best swede year ever).... I'm not saying he's some young stud, but value-wise he's definitely more then a 5th, why was he selected as a throw away prospect?

[tyler]

7. NEW GM RULE

7-1 : If entered into the league between April and December, new GM must wait 14 days from your entry to make a trade. This rule is to allow time to familiarize the new GM with the league and the player’s value according to the league

Our CBA is a fuckin joke.

[MSP4LYFE]

19 year old dman playing in the SEL, 3rd round pick from a much stronger draft (best swede year ever).... I'm not saying he's some young stud, but value-wise he's definitely more then a 5th, why was he selected as a throw away prospect?

He was a low third, and bringing up the strength of Swedes in that draft is stupid, he didn't contribute to it, he was a project defensive d-man at the time, and still is to this day. The chances of that coming back to bite Carolina are slim to none, I won't argue that there were others who could have been moved before him, but at the end of the day the difference is negligible..

[MSP4LYFE]

7. NEW GM RULE

7-1 : If entered into the league between April and December, new GM must wait 14 days from your entry to make a trade. This rule is to allow time to familiarize the new GM with the league and the player’s value according to the league

He's been a member for much longer than 2 weeks...

[tyler]

member of the forum .. not a GM. This rule is stated for new GM's.... and with these trades obvously he doesnt know our value.

[MSP4LYFE]

member of the forum .. not a GM. This rule is stated for new GM's.... and with these trades obvously he doesnt know our value.

Show me where the rulebook distinguishes between the two?

As for the trade comment, that's a matter of opinion.

[tyler]

show you where it distinguishes the two???? OK

7. NEW GM RULE

7-1 : If entered into the league between April and December, new GM must wait 14 days from your entry to make a trade. This rule is to allow time to familiarize the new GM with the league and the player’s value according to the league

no where in our CBA says if the person is part of our forum for any lenght of time the trade clause gets lifted. Give your guys head a shake. i sent my issue to mr. bruin, the head of CC .. ill let it be dealt with the proper way ( the one we made rules about)

[Scott]

You guys have got to be kidding me with bitching about this. Whatever, I'll take the heat but it's a little pathetic that Bertilsson can cause people to bitch and moan.

[MSP4LYFE]

show you where it distinguishes the two???? OK

7. NEW GM RULE

7-1 : If entered into the league between April and December, new GM must wait 14 days from your entry to make a trade. This rule is to allow time to familiarize the new GM with the league and the player’s value according to the league

no where in our CBA says if the person is part of our forum for any lenght of time the trade clause gets lifted. Give your guys head a shake. i sent my issue to mr. bruin, the head of CC .. ill let it be dealt with the proper way ( the one we made rules about)

There is no specification that you need to be a GM, it merely says GM, nor does it say being entered in the league, in any capacity doesn't count towards the limit.

PM whoever you want, I don't care, it isn't changing.

[MSP4LYFE]

You guys have got to be kidding me with bitching about this. Whatever, I'll take the heat but it's a little pathetic that Bertilsson can cause people to bitch and moan.

Must be beach day in Van City, because they all have sand in their vagina's...

[Nick]

Come on Scott & Kareem... new gm is losing value in trades, shouldn't be pumping through deals without some more assistance from bcool.

[MSP4LYFE]

Come on Scott & Kareem... new gm is losing value in trades, shouldn't be pumping through deals without some more assistance from bcool.

Nick hates Koreans, that's what this is all about.