O-M-GOLIGOSKI

[Robin Hood]

player scores, spotlight hits him, goal light comes on, fans go crazy.

[anton]

i would've gone with "goaligoski"

or

goligodski

or

goalie-go-ski

or

goaliegodski

or

goldigoski

[Scott]

Not a fan of that banner

[Nick]

Hard to see him, but I think I like it.

[Shep]

Back to back flops IMO.

Not a fan of these last 2.

[Robin Hood]

Back to back flops IMO.

Not a fan of these last 2.

lol normally i listen to any critique. but you are way off base here. its better than the ryan one you have up imo though i know people here love your banners so they probably won't agree .

[Nick]

Neither of those 2 are either of your best work; just a note though -> it isn't good practice to respond to a critique with a criticism. Progress is made through making use of the comments offered up by other 'experts' -> each man is only as successful as those who push him to be, it's not how many times you've been knocked down that matters, it's how many times you've gotten up, etc.


Personally I think the original Bobby Ryan " roaring" signature is the best the BBKL has seen


This is the best one that has been made for me, too bad I switched teams soon after.

[bills09]

I love the Ryan one.

[Robin Hood]

Neither of those 2 are either of your best work; just a note though -> it isn't good practice to respond to a critique with a criticism. Progress is made through making use of the comments offered up by other 'experts' -> each man is only as successful as those who push him to be, it's not how many times you've been knocked down that matters, it's how many times you've gotten up, etc.

lol i take criticism fine 99% of the time. i just dont think a banner has ever been made that shows everything that happens after a goal, which is why i like this one so much.

that being said the hartford whalers bobby ryan one and islander jvr one are probably shep's two best banners ever. id say my best is the clutterbuck one i made for neel and the cammaleri one for chuck.

[Shep]

We both clearly have different eyes in the graphic world then, Shiv. Because if you want me to be blunt, I think your recent two are two of your worst banners. And the two you think are my two best, are middle of the pack at best for me.



I usually never comment on the ones I don't like, because I don't like to criticize.

On your current one, for example. It's got way too many vibrant colours, if I wasn't a hockey fan I'd have NO idea what was going on there. It looks like a mash up of pixels that are having an orgy. But not a lesbian orgy, more like an orgy of naked homeless dudes.

Party.

And your Cammalleri one is 100% your best. Probably the best banner on this site.

[Robin Hood]

We both clearly have different eyes in the graphic world then, Shiv. Because if you want me to be blunt, I think your recent two are two of your worst banners. And the two you think are my two best, are middle of the pack at best for me.



I usually never comment on the ones I don't like, because I don't like to criticize.

On your current one, for example. It's got way too many vibrant colours, if I wasn't a hockey fan I'd have NO idea what was going on there. It looks like a mash up of pixels that are having an orgy. But not a lesbian orgy, more like an orgy of naked homeless dudes.

Party.

And your Cammalleri one is 100% your best. Probably the best banner on this site.

LOL yeah see for me your banners use colours that are too desaturated imo. i say this as a constructive critique btw. i remember i once told you your alfredsson banner was amazing for billys team. but imo it wasnt saturated enough. uniforms dont look pale. the banner was amazing dont get em wrong.

but the colours in this banner are more vibrant than my banners usually have because thats what happens when a goal is scored. think about it. the bright red from the siren comes on, the spot light shines. what i like about this banner the most though is that for me anyways, the fans are depicted really well on the far right - you know theyre banging away at the boards and that goal horn is going off. i dont like the banner as much for its graphic part because yes my other banners i.e. cammalleri are far better. but i like that it captures the moment of when a goal is scored.

i agree could have done a better job with it being less pixelated though.

[Robin Hood]

oh and say what you will but your bobby ryan one is your best ever simply because it captures an unbelievable moment. and you did a great job to put him in a whalers uniform while that was happening. ask anyone in this league. they will cite that one as your best ever.

[Shep]

I didn't even really do anything for my Alfredsson banner. There is nothing too it.

I just think there was a better way to capture the "goal" moment than that.

[Scott]

IMO, the Goligoski banner is terrible.. I think it's ugly as fuck. Sorry Shiv.

[Robin Hood]

IMO, the Goligoski banner is terrible.. I think it's ugly as fuck. Sorry Shiv.

i heard you the first time . but i like it. though in comparison to that toews banner i made you i agree.

[Scott]

IMO, the Goligoski banner is terrible.. I think it's ugly as fuck. Sorry Shiv.

i heard you the first time . but i like it. though in comparison to that toews banner i made you i agree.

Ya, the Toews banner is sick. Definitely one of my favs.

[The BBKL Insider]

hard on the eyes


i get the feeling as if i was doing meth (which i've never done)

[armandtanzarian]

Lol, this must be the thread you were referring to Shiv...haha