Buds Board Keepers League

I guess Letang is considered a Hall of Famer around here lol

cliff11 wroteCOLONhow many cups for EK 65 ?

and?

kyuss wroteCOLONI guess Letang is considered a Hall of Famer around here lol

Definitely a legend.

Good Canadian boys win cups. Ek just pads stats for contract.

The BBKL Insider wroteCOLON

cliff11 wroteCOLONhow many cups for EK 65 ?

Letang went to his house for a beer, but EK had no cups.

So they had to go to Letangs, so they could each enjoy a beer and could even invite a friend.

Lmao

The BBKL Insider wroteCOLONOne is past his prime and the other is just coming into it.

This is correct. I'll give you hint about it: one is 31yrs old, the other is 28

kyuss wroteCOLON

cliff11 wroteCOLONhow many cups for EK 65 ?

and?

thats all I was saying, Im sure if Letang was a euro your tune might be a tad different tune just joking around here guys thats all

kyuss wroteCOLON

The BBKL Insider wroteCOLONOne is past his prime and the other is just coming into it.

This is correct. I'll give you hint about it: one is 31yrs old, the other is 28

The 28 year old is playing like he is 37.

Damn, how is that when he plays like a 37yrs old he still looks so much better than Letang?

Anyways, how about this: from next season onward, any year Karlsson will score more pts than Letang you'll give me a pick. Any year Letang will have more pts than Karlsson (i.e. Karlsson will be injured) I'll give you a pick in the same round.

This until one of them retires.

Deal?

I'll be kind and let you decide which round, so the picks could be 7th rounders, to let you an easy way out of this.

I hear what you are asking for, good luck lol.

Karlson asking for 15mil per season in an extension. So he probably gets 12+....teams need to know they are taking that on. His value should be at an all time low.

you seem very concerned about my team, Steve. Considering how good your team is, I don't see why.

Too bad you're backing out and not taking that deal though.

Erik Karlsson at 12 would not be overpaid, unlike Letang at 7.5

The BBKL Insider wroteCOLONI hear what you are asking for, good luck lol.

contrary to what this thread might suggest, I'm not asking for a Hall of Famer back.

I did reject 34 yrs old Ryan Suter though

I wasn't expecting to trigger a multi-page debate...Mik, I just wanted to know hypothetically if Letang would've interested you now compared to when we talked before.

We all have preferences on which players we like...that's fair. I don't personally like Letang either...mostly because of Red Wings-Penguins battles of the past...but I can't deny that the guy has had a really good career.

its a good day to BBKL haha

kyuss wroteCOLONnot looking for adding cap in the deal (unless it's a minor difference)

Considering EK is about to make 13+ next season, not sure how Carlson doesn't get considered.

- EK dictates the play, Carlson's production is contingent on where he plays..

- Carlson makes 1.5M more this season

- I don't think EK will make more than McDavid lol

kyuss wroteCOLON- EK dictates the play, Carlson's production is contingent on where he plays..

- Carlson makes 1.5M more this season

- I don't think EK will make more than McDavid lol

Cap inflation+ufa contract vs buying out ufa years for McDavid. He will for sure have offers in that range on the open market and plenty of teams with cash to open their pocketbooks.

And what does it matter whos better in real life? Especially considering EK's cap hit will be 35-40% higher than Carlson's for likely similar fantasy production. Carlson at 8m is easily more valuable than EK at 13 in this league.

CasperX22 wroteCOLON

kyuss wroteCOLON- EK dictates the play, Carlson's production is contingent on where he plays..

- Carlson makes 1.5M more this season

- I don't think EK will make more than McDavid lol

Cap inflation+ufa contract vs buying out ufa years for McDavid. He will for sure have offers in that range on the open market and plenty of teams with cash to open their pocketbooks.

And what does it matter whos better in real life? Especially considering EK's cap hit will be 35-40% higher than Carlson's for likely similar fantasy production.

that's only your speculation. I don't see EK going to a crappy team just to get 12M... he's more likely to make 9.5 on a contender

And the day, for whatever reason, Carlson is off that PP unit his production gets cut in half, unlike EK who makes his own points anyway

He's going to get the 7 years by 11M is my guess or from SJS he will get 8 years at 11M

cliff11 wroteCOLONHe's going to get the 7 years by 11M is my guess or from SJS he will get 8 years at 11M

Yep.

Is this an EK vs. Letang debate? Why debate the undebatable?