Buds Board Keepers League

bills09 wroteCOLONOh BBKL's on its rag again

facey wroteCOLONBecause unless clearly outlined the appeal process will be abused and this whole thing to waste.

Why didn't you voice any of these concerns while the CC was discussing and asking for opinions? I know you noted that Marleau and Joki were iffy on the top 4 list, however the other criteria we've worked to come up with supports Marleau as a C and Joki as a W

-> so moving foward is it a good idea that an amendment to the positional listing can be made if the player in question meets a) Top 4 FOT however has b) FOT < 450 & c) FOR <.3 ?

kyuss wroteCOLON

SuperMario wroteCOLONYeah this isnt a discussion to be honest. Somehow Jussi Jokinen is listed as a winger and instead of saying yes that can be reevaluated, you have just said tough luck.

not true.. and a disappointing post overall. Looks like i have waisted all day.

Things will be revaluated if it will be considered a worth improvement overall.

The case of Iginla is more convincing than Jokinen's one, because he has a lower FOR and he clearly won't be over .3 next season, whereas for Jussi, by the likes of Canes lineup, it's anyone's guess.
Another convincing argument would be if these criteria would indeed bring too many centers.

still waiting for your population btw.

Habber wroteCOLON

kyuss wroteCOLON

SuperMario wroteCOLONYeah this isnt a discussion to be honest. Somehow Jussi Jokinen is listed as a winger and instead of saying yes that can be reevaluated, you have just said tough luck.

not true.. and a disappointing post overall. Looks like i have waisted all day.

Things will be revaluated if it will be considered a worth improvement overall.

The case of Iginla is more convincing than Jokinen's one, because he has a lower FOR and he clearly won't be over .3 next season, whereas for Jussi, by the likes of Canes lineup, it's anyone's guess.
Another convincing argument would be if these criteria would indeed bring too many centers.

still waiting for your population btw.

I can shed some light on Jokinen because I owned him most of last year until I sent hi mto Shiv. Jokinen started the first month or two at center for the Canes, where most of his FOW came from. Then they shifted him to wing and only took occasional draws. He's a grey area cause they suited him up at both center and wing for extended periods of time.