Re: NHL Transactions, Injuries & Rumours
PostedCOLON Mon Jul 22, 2013 3:00 pm
I don't like it, but I'd bet a boat load of money that Iginla, Boyle and Richards make TC.
The Ultimate Fantasy Hockey Experience
http://nhlnotes.com/bbkl/
Neither Girardi nor Hamhuis deserve to be in the same sentence as Dion Phaneuf. Phaneuf played more minutes then both and against harder competition, was the anchor on the second best PK, and out-produced both offensively. These are not opinions, they are facts.shooker wroteCOLONA guy I think got robbed of an invite is Dan Girardi of the NYR. Guy has been nothing short of amazing back there. I think he is right around Hamhuis and Phaneuf as the 8-9-10 guys on the list, but he deserves to be in the discussion imo.
Richards yes. The other two I don't know.MSP4LYFE wroteCOLONI don't like it, but I'd bet a boat load of money that Iginla, Boyle and Richards make TC.
So he is out of their league in bbkl. Not real life I am sorry to say it.MSP4LYFE wroteCOLONNeither Girardi nor Hamhuis deserve to be in the same sentence as Dion Phaneuf. Phaneuf played more minutes then both and against harder competition, was the anchor on the second best PK, and out-produced both offensively. These are not opinions, they are facts.shooker wroteCOLONA guy I think got robbed of an invite is Dan Girardi of the NYR. Guy has been nothing short of amazing back there. I think he is right around Hamhuis and Phaneuf as the 8-9-10 guys on the list, but he deserves to be in the discussion imo.
Your opinion on this subject means nothing to me because it runs counter to all of the evidence that we have at our disposal. If a player looks good, is trusted by his coach, earns the respect and captaincy of his team, produces at en elite rate, and is rated as an elite player by advanced statistical measures then chances are he is an elite player...shooker wroteCOLONSo he is out of their league in bbkl. Not real life I am sorry to say it.
Seabrook over Subban? Seabrook was so bad last year that Hjalmarsson passed him as the #2 on the Hawks, whereas Subban is coming off a career year as one of the top offensive D in the NHL.SuperMario wroteCOLONKunitz - Crosby - Nash
Stamkos - Giroux - Tavares
Getzlaf - Toews - Perry
E. Staal - Bergeron - J. Staal
Doughty-Weber
Seabrook-Keith
Phaneuf-Letang
Price
Luongo
Sorry but I HAVE to post this lol...MSP4LYFE wroteCOLONYour opinion on this subject means nothing to me because it runs counter to all of the evidence that we have at our disposal. If a player looks good, is trusted by his coach, earns the respect and captaincy of his team, produces at en elite rate, and is rated as an elite player by advanced statistical measures then chances are he is an elite player...shooker wroteCOLONSo he is out of their league in bbkl. Not real life I am sorry to say it.
No way Seabrook doesn't make the team IMO. Him and Keith are a lock to be a pair. Subban could make it though in place of a Letang for example.MSP4LYFE wroteCOLONSeabrook over Subban? Seabrook was so bad last year that Hjalmarsson passed him as the #2 on the Hawks, whereas Subban is coming off a career year as one of the top offensive D in the NHL.SuperMario wroteCOLONKunitz - Crosby - Nash
Stamkos - Giroux - Tavares
Getzlaf - Toews - Perry
E. Staal - Bergeron - J. Staal
Doughty-Weber
Seabrook-Keith
Phaneuf-Letang
Price
Luongo
That poll is a joke.Chuck Norris wroteCOLONSorry but I HAVE to post this lol...MSP4LYFE wroteCOLONYour opinion on this subject means nothing to me because it runs counter to all of the evidence that we have at our disposal. If a player looks good, is trusted by his coach, earns the respect and captaincy of his team, produces at en elite rate, and is rated as an elite player by advanced statistical measures then chances are he is an elite player...shooker wroteCOLONSo he is out of their league in bbkl. Not real life I am sorry to say it.
http://www.tsn.ca/nhl/story/?id=384805
BAHAHAHAHA
Don't even qualify that post with a response.SuperMario wroteCOLONThat poll is a joke.
If you look at all advanced metrics on Phaneuf, he is a terrific d-man. Sure he makes mistakes but as do all d-men playing similar roles.
Don't even think you're being a Habs fan here. Many fan bases seem to think Phaneuf is bad including part of the Leaf fan base, which is absolutely ridiculous.
I wish more fans looked at advanced stats.
The poll makes no sense, ask most people about Phaneuf and they will tell you he flat out sucks, how can someone be overrated if everyone thinks they suck? The same thing goes for Scott Gomez.Sensfanjosh wroteCOLONI dunno Chuck, Ovy, Kovy, Lecavalier, Kesler, Iginla are pretty solid players I'd say too....
If he plays the way he did last season he won't even be a consideration.SuperMario wroteCOLONNo way Seabrook doesn't make the team IMO. Him and Keith are a lock to be a pair. Subban could make it though in place of a Letang for example.
The Kunitz thing, everyone will call me crazy but aside from Crosby's Golden Goal in 2010, he wasn't all that great in the Olympics. Linemates were constantly swapped in and out. Kunitz may not be a lock but he has a good chance on that fact alone -> investing a roster spot to ensure Crosby is playing his best.
St. Louis is the only player I really struggled with. Almost feel bad for him because he will likely get left out again.