Buds Board Keepers League

Poll.

Yes

or

No

i dont know how to vote on this one

Yes - becuase it keeps them active

No - because the other half of the league can't.

Yes. Keeps gm active and mirrors the nhl rule allowing trades for non playoff teams.

Will wait to vote on this as i need to think..

Can't non playoff teams just agree to trades in principle and then announce them at the conclusion of the playoffs?

Bruyns wroteCOLONCan't non playoff teams just agree to trades in principle and then announce them at the conclusion of the playoffs?

when we used to be allowed to trade playoff teams would do this very thing and after they were eliminated they would post. No rule against discussing trades period and trades were made in every year this very way. Although, last year there were basically no trades because people did not log in very often during the playoffs.

!Support

i vote yes, i think it keeps the league active

Note.

Playoff teams can trade once eliminated from playoffs. It is not a case in which if you made the playoffs, you have to wait for the conclusion of them to trade. You just have to wait for you own playoff exit.


At least that is the NHL rule and the one we used to use.

shooker wroteCOLONNote.

Playoff teams can trade once eliminated from playoffs. It is not a case in which if you made the playoffs, you have to wait for the conclusion of them to trade. You just have to wait for you own playoff exit.


At least that is the NHL rule and the one we used to use.

seems logical to me

shooker wroteCOLONNote.

Playoff teams can trade once eliminated from playoffs. It is not a case in which if you made the playoffs, you have to wait for the conclusion of them to trade. You just have to wait for you own playoff exit.


At least that is the NHL rule and the one we used to use.

Yeah, this should go without saying..

Although I tried to say it in the poll header but there's a 100 character max.

kimmer wroteCOLON!Support

great, don't know which side though.

Wtf !support means yes !deny means no

kimmer wroteCOLONWtf !support means yes !deny means no

K what does adding ! in front of words !mean?

I'm old, I don't get this crap.

Maybe its the hashtag for instagram or something

#dontgiveafuck

Thats not a very good attitude Arian.

KapG wroteCOLONThats not a very good attitude Arian.

he is going through his teen years, what else would you expect?

ya bro i'm rebellious

seriously though i just wanted to use a hash tag and i don't really care because i don't make that many trades to begin with. i can wait a month if needed.

-1 on attitude. Def not something we can all do.




I vote no. Not because I make the playoffs ( I voted no back when I missed as well) -> but rather because of actual practice differences.

During the NHL playoffs, no teams make big trades, if they do, they're held off announcing them until after the playoffs, because the playoffs should be all anyone gives an F about. 52 weeks in the year, 6 week trade deadline + 4 weeks of playoffs to not post a trade doesn't seems like a problem to me. 42 weeks to post trades, many of the non-playoff teams are inactive throughout many of those weeks as it stands. All I see it as it for teams that miss or are knocked out early a chance to make some drama, "blowing it up, non-playoff teams get a chance at championship pieces, etc".

Trading is awesome, the talks are one of, if not the, best aspects of the league. Yet by making the playoffs (and/or going on a deep run) you are left out of talks?

-> Just confirm and post later you say? Great, everyone should follow those rules.


For reality's sake, we should be clear: The NHL doesn't say 'no trades during the playoffs' -> trade deadline day is the last day players are eligible for playoffs.

If for some reason a team lost its goalies to injury before the last game of the season, they could trade for another goalie. But that player wouldn't be eligible for the playoffs.