Buds Board Keepers League

To Philadelphia:
Brian Campbell
2011 4th (SJS)
2011 5th (DET)

To Detroit:
Eric Brewer
Nigel Williams
Evgeny Artyukhin
2011 3rd (NYR)

Confirmed

eeek.. shoalzie.. why?

facey wroteCOLONeeek.. shoalzie.. why?

I don't understand it either...Maybe if Arty re-signs, but thats a big ? at this point.

I'm sure moving Campbell would've been pretty tough for something very good.. unless you're me haha

Typical scott self-complimenting comment


But why bother moving Campbell at a low when you don't have cap-ceiling issues???

He's never going to be worth his contract and it'll be an albatross until it's gone. Brewer is a risk but he hits some other nice categories plus I move up in the draft to the 3rd round plus a couple other pieces. It's not a great return but I didn't exactly throw him away.

Shoalzie wroteCOLONHe's never going to be worth his contract and it'll be an albatross until it's gone. Brewer is a risk but he hits some other nice categories plus I move up in the draft to the 3rd round plus a couple other pieces. It's not a great return but I didn't exactly throw him away.

I agree with all of the above, and if this was Shiv/Bryan/Shep/Scott/Neel/Kyle/etc making this sort of deal I could understand, but you shouldn't care if he's worth his cap, as your not approaching the ceiling or forking out the pay-checks, just getting the h2h #'s and he's better then what you got.

facey wroteCOLONTypical scott self-complimenting comment


But why bother moving Campbell at a low when you don't have cap-ceiling issues???

hahaha.. I don't do it that much

Raptactics wroteCOLONhahaha.. I don't do it that much

No comment

shoalzie, i dont know if you remember but this is what you gave up for campbell:

To Detroit

Brian Campbell


To Pittsburgh

1st in 2011 WSH
3rd in 2010 TOR
3rd in 2011 PHX
4th in 2011 DET
5th in 2011 SJS

why make this trade after the one you made to land campbell? nick is right you were WAY better off keeping him than giving him up for what you got. you couldve at least held him for a while until you got the proper return.

SuperMario wroteCOLONshoalzie, i dont know if you remember but this is what you gave up for campbell:

To Detroit

Brian Campbell


To Pittsburgh

1st in 2011 WSH
3rd in 2010 TOR
3rd in 2011 PHX
4th in 2011 DET
5th in 2011 SJS

why make this trade after the one you made to land campbell? nick is right you were WAY better off keeping him than giving him up for what you got. you couldve at least held him for a while until you got the proper return.

Yet another bad deal by Detroit. Let's make a deal Detroit. pm me and we could work something out