Buds Board Keepers League

To Penguins

Jimmy Howard
Alexei Ponikarovsky
2nd Round 2010 SJS


To Sabres

Henrik Lundqvist



Yes, I know. Go ahead. Say it. I got raped.

confirmed

Great trade, Shiv...seriously! You know how big of a Howie slap I am...

RAPEEEEEEEEEEEEEee

J/K nice deal boys

MSP4LYFE wroteCOLONRAPEEEEEEEEEEEEEee

J/K nice deal boys

i think you were right when you said rape.

def not rape.


dunno what to think really.


good goalies... one is the best in the world IMO... but the other is younger, cheaper, and on a notably better team... but not truly proven

there should be a forum thread for therapy after you get owned in a deal.

SuperMario wroteCOLONthere should be a forum thread for therapy after you get owned in a deal.

SuperMario wroteCOLONthere should be a forum thread for therapy after you get owned in a deal.

i find it very funny how similar the post-trade comments of Scott, Steve, and Shiv are so similar.

I got raped

I'll regret this one

New guy really worked me

:rape


you guys are sooooooooooooo tricky & original

no way, thats a good old fashion hockey trade

no rape about it

SuperMario wroteCOLONthere should be a forum thread for therapy after you get owned in a deal.

Thinking of your victims for once eh shiv?

you guys are all hilarious, none of you make deals without thinking you won it. Simple.
Your definition of rape is just not as much win as your used to.

Def not rape..I really like what Shiv got.

Howard is prob going to be staying in Detroit for awhile, so that being said shiv, good deal man, nothing wrong with that, Osgoode looked like a gem because Detroit is that good, not to take anything from Howard, he is good and going to get better imo

jcarton wroteCOLONHoward is prob going to be staying in Detroit for awhile, so that being said shiv, good deal man, nothing wrong with that, Osgoode looked like a gem because Detroit is that good, not to take anything from Howard, he is good and going to get better imo

Howards another year at sub 1 million too. Going to put up more wins and as good stats as Lundqvist IMO. Shiv just saved a bunch of cap, hes making a run for it this year.

inferno31 wroteCOLON

jcarton wroteCOLONHoward is prob going to be staying in Detroit for awhile, so that being said shiv, good deal man, nothing wrong with that, Osgoode looked like a gem because Detroit is that good, not to take anything from Howard, he is good and going to get better imo

Howards another year at sub 1 million too. Going to put up more wins and as good stats as Lundqvist IMO. Shiv just saved a bunch of cap, hes making a run for it this year.

Yep..basically Shiv knows he robbed Buffalo and is just full of shit.

bcool wroteCOLON
Yep..basically Shiv knows he robbed Buffalo and is just full of shit.

lol theres NO WAY i robbed Buffalo. A bonafide 70+ starts 35+ wins 2.3 gaa 0.920 sv% for at LEAST the next 7 years(huge understatement btw) is what i traded. I got a goalie who is good for now yes. but what if howard pulls a mason? or price? or theodore? or lehtonen? the list keeps going of one hit wonders. now i dont think howard is a one hit wonder. but the gap between him and lundqvist is huge.

what this deal does let me do though, is keep the twins, datsyuk, and the rest of my roster together. so to me the question wasn't "who is better lundqvist or howard + poni" because the answer to that imo is Lundqvist HANDS DOWN. But the question to me was: What's better for my team, Losing one of the Sedins/Datsyuk but keeping Lundqvist OR Keeping all three and getting Howard. I chose the 2nd. I dont know at all if i was right to still. theres no way to say if i made the right decision. But if you look at the trade in isolation, Buffalo won this deal FOR SURE.

I agree with Shiv. Lunqvist is a bonafide stud and had a tough year last season. Imo, Howard's average and a product of his team. I guess we'll see next year.

Raptactics wroteCOLONI agree with Shiv. Lunqvist is a bonafide stud and had a tough year last season. Imo, Howard's average and a product of his team. I guess we'll see next year.

exactly.

SuperMario wroteCOLON

Raptactics wroteCOLONI agree with Shiv. Lunqvist is a bonafide stud and had a tough year last season. Imo, Howard's average and a product of his team. I guess we'll see next year.

exactly.

Product of your team, in fantasy terms means the same thing as bonafide stud when talking about goalies, just thorwing that out there.

He had a stellar save percentage, and single handely kept his team in it this regular season.
Osgood is the product of a team, and did shit in most regular seasons too.
Howards a great goalie, shiv saved cap and kept his team together. He wins it easy, for next year anyway. After that, we'll see.